Is Freud’s Interpretation Of Dreams Badly Flawed ?

Is Freud's Interpretation Of Dreams Badly Flawed ?

No,I am not going to shed light on Freud’s classic work ” The Interpretation of Dreams” but it’s simply a take on his methodology, which I feel does not do justice given the huge discrepancies which one notices in character of an individual. Now let’s analyze the cases, wherein an individual describes that he/she is flying in the dream. As per Freud, this is indicative of repressed sexual desires. Let’s examine this view of Freud in a critical way. I agree with one of my friend’s Jayashree view that Freud’s views are result of intensive studies that he conducted over decades.However, I am of the opinion that it’s entirely impossible to have accurate prediction on basis of these studies. Freud like Chiero came up with right predictions because he had knack in hitting upon the right meaning, being in league with some sort of god-gifted ability to predict accurately. However, for rest of us, it’s entirely impossible to be confident in predictions based on what we come to read in his books.

Before I present my view, it would be interesting to anticipate the view of Jayashree: “I see him (Sigmund Freud) as someone who had the guts to speak about a lot of things people did not want to accept. He was realistic, born way too early in time; it showed in his ideas and in his attitude. His theory may seem like a lot of crap, but it was based on intensive studies that he conducted over decades, and he included things he learnt from introspection of his own self. Like when he spoke about repressed memories, there was a time when he had memories about being sexually abused by his father though he was not sure his memories were true. Thus, he mentions in the theory that no one can be sure recalled memories can be absolutely right. Freud’s theory has not been completely disproved because he left everything to doubt. He was sure that the mind, such an extremely complex thing, could not be explained like a mathematical formula. Nothing, in this field, is absolutely black or white.”

Now let’s be more critical in anticipating that when you fly in dreams, you are more or less in grip of repressed sexual desires. Repression that differs from suppression in a sense that it occurs consciously while the latter is a conscious effort- a matter of choice. It’s not the case with repression, which is usually involuntary. Well, I am not challenging Freud’s view but I do feel that had flying been linked with repressed sexual desires nearly every teen would have talked about flying in the air experience . Or for that matter , since repressed desires for sexual intercourse is integral part of Indian people psyche at some point in their lives nearly every Indian should have flying experiences at great speed. Is that’s the case? No.

I agree that we Indians do have repressed sexual desires, more so in age marred by globalization, when movies, debates on gender issues like live-in-relationships convey the impression that having intercourse is the most important phenomenon of human life .However, since we are more or less guided by morals and ethical values, a dilemma of intense nature revolving around sexual preference has become order of things. So according to Freud every Indian should be flying at great speed but I don’t think that’s the case. So what’s the solution ? Get above such desires by fulfilling them? Having done that if one gets above such repressed sexual desires, can one claim that dream in which one flies in great speed would stop? In lighter vein, my friend Jayashree feels that if she comes to fly in dreams it’s all because she reads Harry Potter too much!

Anyway, I feel that Freud was so successful in arriving at right interpretations because he was gifted or in other words there was X factor too. For example, Cheiro has left behind number of books related with occult science but that has not produced masters like Cheiro. Even Cheiro was not able to interpret in light of his theories during his last phase of life because that X factor was now missing. In sum, it’s highly dangerous to rely on fixed line of interpretations while intercepting mysterious phenomenons of nature. In my eyes, there are many flaws in psychological assumptions, which makes healing in case of mental disorders a tough task.

One of the psychologist in a conversation with me revealed that medicines used in disorders merely suppress the symptoms. They in no way lead to removal of symptoms in totality. At this point, I a would again like to quote words of Jayashree: ” People suffering mental disorders don’t show a very good prognosis because because we aren’t equipped to deal with such delicate matters yet. Much of the human brain remains unknown; the effects of what goes on in there is even less comprehensible. What’s more, we live in a world where what is sane or not is decided by the majority who change their mind every alternate day. And it isn’t a very easy job to cure a mental disorder when the ’curer’ is just as liable to develop the disorder. None of us are immune to it; at the end of the day, no matter how hard we try, the disorder has the last laugh.”

If that’s the case, I feel it’s highly dangerous to rely too much upon psychological theories as that would more often than not produce fallacious interpretations. Psychological assumptions often leave one in the lurch.Probably, this is why many people suffering from psychological disorders fail to show any sign of progress despite being treated amid state-of-the-art facilities . Whether you accept it or not, the modern psychological theories have many missing links.

Today it has become some sort of a fashion to quote Freud even as there is no substantial basis to approve the validity of Freud’s hypothesis in tackling cases of myriad types. Let’s not be guided by them in a blind way, becoming open to better ways to tackle the mysterious world of human brain. The human brain is much more complex in its functioning and therefore it would be lethal to anticipate it with flawed notions, views and theories.

Is Freud's Interpretation Of Dreams Badly Flawed ?

References:

The Interpretation Of Dreams

Sigmund Freud

Pics Credit :

Pic One

Pic Two 

19 responses

  1. […] Is Freud’s Interpretation Of Dreams Badly Flawed ? (indowaves.wordpress.com) […]

    1. Thanks a lot for making my article a part of an extremely well written article of yours.

  2. […] Is Freud’s Interpretation Of Dreams Badly Flawed ? (indowaves.wordpress.com) […]

    1. Thanks a lot for making my article a part of your article.

  3. […] Is Freud’s Interpretation Of Dreams Badly Flawed ? (indowaves.wordpress.com) […]

    1. Thanks friend for making my write-up a part of your article as a reference article.

  4. […] Is Freud’s Interpretation Of Dreams Badly Flawed ? (indowaves.wordpress.com) […]

    1. @F M SAHOO, Ph.D
      (Professor of Psychology and Management and The Author of Several Books on Child Psychology, Human Behavior, Stress Management )

      I really feel honoured to see my article tagged with your post as one of the related articles. And yes, I read your article. I am sure it would help souls trying to rise above unpleasant memories!!!

      Here is the link :

      Can you force yourself to forget ?

      http://atlasofmind.wordpress.com/2011/05/22/force-yourself-to-forget/

  5. […] Is Freud’s Interpretation Of Dreams Badly Flawed ? (indowaves.wordpress.com) […]

    1. Thanks F M SAHOOji for making this article part of your post once again. Your kind gesture makes me feel great.

  6. Interpretation of anything changes with the amount of time the human lives and the past memories forgotten or unsolved in the human brain

    The human brain interprets stillness or past actions and reactions that become memories of past and never the future that hasn’t yet been lived

    1. One should learn the art of right interpretation!!!

      1. Who is to say, what is the right interpretation ? and taught by whom!

    2. @ Just Me Again

      It doesn’t matter who presents it but it’s never a difficult task to intercept the right interpretation. One easily senses that it’s the right one whenever it makes its presence felt..

      1. I hope you realize how unrealistic your interpretation of my statement is by you presenting the impossible plausible solution to the many imperfect mind formed minds that can only find the interpretations of the stronger mind formers and is why there is no common thoughts between all humans on earth

        If one was mind formed to live in a world of pretends,maybes and impossible wants, then that human is probably in a better place than the fewer humans who suffer from the real world of logic

    3. @JustMeAgain

      If there is no right way of interpretation many would not be able to get the right meaning of JustMeAgain’s meandering statements🙂 So whether the interpretation flows from the stronger mind or the weaker mind one has to arrive at proper interpretation in order to get at the core of the things coming from the types of Just Me Again!!!

      1. Interpretations of a so-called consciousness species and the results of those so – called interpretations are judged by nature alone, and in nature’s hopes of the right interpretations that will keep natures consciousness alive until nature can by itself can think what directions are best for natures consciousness —-forever

        No-one should ever think they can gain correct interpretation from another human of the same species ,,,,,,,thoughts

        The world is a mess from the delusional thinking that there are understandings among the warring human species that are plagued by misinterpretations

        There is nothing more dreamy in thought than the human species!

    4. “No-one should ever think they can gain correct interpretation from another human of the same species ,,,,,,,thoughts”

      ..I agree in strict metaphysical terms one can say all interpretations are relative but I must say that in normal practical sense one has limited scope to challenge the interpretation of evolved souls arrived at after thorough study of the case. In other words, in ours world there is always a better interpretation applicable for all🙂

      1. I will leave you with your last thoughts of the interpretation of the previous interpretive thoughts, all never finding any absolute conclusion

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

The great Rudolf Steiner Quotes Site

Quotes and fragments from the work of the great visionary, thinker and reformer Rudolf Steiner

Bhavanajagat

Welcome to Noble Thoughts from All Directions to promote the well-being of man and to know the purpose in Life.

Serendipity

Was I born a masochist or did society make me this way? I demand unconditional love and complete freedom. That is why I am terrible.

John SterVens' Tales

Thee Life, Thee Heart, Thee Tears

Indowaves's Blog

Just another WordPress.com weblog

Una voce nonostante tutto

Ognuno ha il diritto di immaginarsi fuori dagli schemi

Personal Concerns

My Thoughts and Views Frankly Expressed

I love a lot

Just another WordPress.com site

the wuc

a broth of thoughts, stories, wucs and wit.

A Little Bit of Monica

My take on international politics, travel, and history...

Atlas of Mind

Its all about Human Mind & Behavior..

Peru En Route

Tips to travel around Perú.

Health & Family

A healthy balance of the mind, body and spirit

मानसिक हलचल

ज्ञानदत्त पाण्डेय का हिन्दी ब्लॉग। मैं यह ब्लॉग लिखने के अलावा गाँव विक्रमपुर, जिला भदोही, उत्तरप्रदेश, भारत में रह कर ग्रामीण जीवन जानने का प्रयास कर रहा हूँ। रेलवे से ज़ोनल रेलवे के विभागाध्यक्ष के पद से रिटायर्ड अफसर।

Monoton+Minimal

travel adventures

Stand up for your rights

Gender biased laws

The Bach

Me, my scribbles and my ego

Tuesdays with Laurie

"Whatever you are not changing, you are choosing." —Laurie Buchanan

%d bloggers like this: